MPs move to block Theresa May from signing ‘no deal’ Brexit

Dominic Grieve is among MPs who have tabled amendments to the EU withdrawal bill. Photograph: Linda Nylind/the Guardian

Cross-party group draws up plans to make it impossible for PM to allow Britain to crash out of the EU without a deal

A powerful cross-party group of MPs is drawing up plans that would make it impossible for Theresa May to allow Britain to crash out of the EU without a deal in 2019. The move comes amid new warnings that a “cliff-edge” Brexit would be catastrophic for the economy.

One critical aim of the group – which includes the former Tory chancellor Kenneth Clarke and several Conservative ex-ministers, together with prominent Labour, SNP, Liberal Democrat and Green MPs – is to give parliament the ability to veto, or prevent by other legal means, a “bad deal” or “no deal” outcome.

Concern over Brexit policy reached new heights this weekend after the prime minister told the House of Commons that her government was spending £250m on preparations for a possible “no deal” result because negotiations with Brussels had stalled.

Several hundred amendments to the EU withdrawal bill include one tabled by the former cabinet minister Dominic Grieve and signed by nine other Tory MPs, together with members of all the other main parties, saying any final deal must be approved by an entirely separate act of parliament.

If passed, this would give the majority of MPs who favour a soft Brexit the binding vote on the final outcome they have been seeking and therefore the ability to reject any “cliff-edge” option.

A separate amendment tabled by Clarke and the former Labour minister Chris Leslie says Theresa May’s plan for a two-year transition period after Brexit – which she outlined in her recent Florence speech – should be written into the withdrawal bill, with an acceptance EU rules and law would continue to apply during that period. If such a transition was not agreed, the amendment says, exit from the EU should not be allowed to happen.

With a sense of crisis engulfing the government and whips fearing a series of Conservative rebellions and defeats over the bill, ministers have been forced to postpone the committee stage of the legislation, which was due to start this week.

Stephen Doughty, a Labour MP who has been part of the behind-the-scenes cross-party efforts to find ways to amend the bill, said: “There is now growing cross-party anger at the absurd suggestion that we could crash out of the EU without a deal, and without even the transitional period that was promised by the PM – let alone that the government is attempting at the same time to give itself sweeping new powers and undermine the devolution settlement. It is clear the prime minister and Brexit secretary now have a real crisis on their hands over this bill and face defeat on a series of issues.”

Leslie said the MPs would continue work to find amendments around which soft-Brexit MPs of all parties could unite to prevent a disastrous outcome for the country.

“In the remaining time before committee stage starts, conversations between MPs across the parties will help identify common ground – and enshrining the transition period into law is increasingly likely if we work together in this way. This bill could be the last chance for parliament to put safeguards in place; it’s too important to miss these opportunities.”

Adam Marshall, the director general of the British Chambers of Commerce, said the business community “wants a transition agreed in principle and trade talks under way by the end of 2017. If there is not that clarity we will start to see the activation of contingency plans and likely significant impact on business investment.”

The 10 Democratic Unionist party MPs, upon whose votes May relies for a Commons majority, have made it clear to government whips that they would not accept a “no deal” outcome because it would mean a return to a hard border between Northern Ireland and the Republic. If May were to try to push such an approach, the deal with the DUP that keeps her in power could fall.

Yesterday, in a sign of growing desperation, it emerged that the Brexit secretary, David Davis, will travel to Brussels on Monday for unscheduled talks after the EU ruled that insufficient progress had been made for the two sides to begin future trade talks with Britain. A key plank of May’s Brexit policy has been her insistence that “no deal is better than a bad deal”. She has made it clear that at the end of negotiations MPs will have only two options: to accept whatever deal is on offer or to agree there will be no deal.

Labour has also tabled a series of amendments that would bind the government to a transitional period, after Brexit day in March 2019, during which the UK in effect would remain inside the single market and customs union. The party’s Brexit spokesman, Keir Starmer, said: “No deal means the return of a hard border in Northern Ireland. No deal means no agreement on how we trade with Europe. No deal means EU nationals working in our schools and hospitals and the 1.2 million UK citizens living in the EU will continue to be unsure about their future. No deal means no deal on aviation, which quite literally means planes cannot take off and land. This is not scaremongering, it’s the grim reality.”

Tory MPS who oppose a hard Brexit have declared they will not back any amendments tabled by Labour’s frontbench and bearing Jeremy Corbyn’s name, but say they would be prepared to line up with amendments from like-minded Labour backbenchers.

The former Tory education secretary Nicky Morgan, who has signed several amendments, said last night that the best way for ministers to avoid a defeat was to agree to give MPs a binding vote on the outcome, “whether or not there is a deal”. She added: “If they test this I think they will find there is a majority for an amendment and no majority for a ‘no deal’ outcome.”

This weekend it is expected that at least one hardline pro-Brexit Tory MP will break cover to call for the suspension of Brexit negotiations until the EU agrees that trade talks can begin. The Observer has also learned that ministers may sanction the first expenditure on preparations for a “no deal” Brexit as soon as Monday, without the full approval of parliament.

Meanwhile, ministers are rushing through a vote on treatment of nuclear material in a move that will allow them to begin spending on the new IT systems and inspectors needed should Britain remain outside Euratom, the EU-wide nuclear regulatory body.

The spending could go ahead after the vote although the legislation is far from receiving full parliamentary approval. It comes amid claims of another “power grab” by ministers over Brexit plans.


  1. 我們彩用國際及美國食品及藥物管理局FDA認可的CO2 激光儀 Lutronics® Spectra SPR, 具安全性, 準確度高 . 二氧化碳激光可安全地去除皮膚上的癦痣、肉粒、疣、老人斑等問題。此激光的幼細光束可準確及直接地將要去除的組織氧化,過程快捷,傷口細小及乾淨,對周圍的皮膚傷害減至最少。一般1-2次就可永久去除。

  2. Sculptra 含有由含有源於植物果酸的 PLLA 聚左乳酸(poly-L-lactic acid),它能促進天然膠原蛋白大量增生,令容顏重現年輕,一個療程的效果能持續逾2年。Sculptra 乃全球唯一獲美國食物及藥物管理局(美國FDA)認可的PLLA聚左乳酸美容品牌。Sculptra 塑然雅會被人體自然分解吸收,同時促進天然膠原蛋白再生1。療程效果可以漸進地給你更富清新朝氣的容頻,效果自然,更不會影響面部表情。SCULPTRA 塑然雅 Sculptra 由含有源於植物果酸的PLLA聚左乳酸(poly-L-lactic acid),它可以被新陳代謝成二氧化碳及水,最終自體內排出。PLLA聚左乳酸早已被廣泛應用於醫療用品超過30年,自2009年起 Sculptra 及全球唯一獲美國FDA認可的PLLA聚左乳酸美容醫學品牌。Sculptra ® 塑然雅能促進天然膠原蛋白大量增生1,改善皺紋,令容顏重現年輕。全球唯一獲美國FDA認可PLLA聚左乳酸。臨床研究證實於3個月間,肌膚的膠原蛋白密度 顯著增加67%2。療程效果能持續愈2年3。主要成份PLLA聚左乳酸源於植物果酸,醫學界廣泛使用超過30年。

  3. 防曬粉 BB粉底霜 亮麗柔滑打底乳液 亮麗柔滑控油打底乳液 有機幹細胞修護CC霜 潤澤防曬底霜 礦物質潤澤慕斯 礦物質奇幻粉餅 礦物質蜜粉 完美礦物粉底 控油定妝蜜粉 高清控油粉餅 控油蜜 保濕滋潤噴霧 有機抗氧爽膚噴霧 有機抗敏保濕

  4. 激光靶向祛痣:對斑痣的顯性症狀能快速控制、甚至消除,短期實現肌膚無暇;多款激光設備深層激活膠原蛋白活性,深層煥發激活生命力。快速補充肌膚活性:根據顧客肌膚特性,醫生配套無創注射項目,為肌膚注入玻尿酸、肉毒素等能直接補充肌膚活性,快速補充肌膚缺失的玻尿酸、膠原蛋白,並能達到年輕態塑型的效果,從膚質和形態上保持年輕。聯合療法:注射玻尿酸、肉毒素等產品、配合精確波長的激光能加速透明質酸、肉毒素等物質的吸收,能極大化提高注射營養物質轉換率,最高達30以上,塑形效果保持3.5個月以上,年輕態效果保持時間延長1年以上。

  5. Venus Viva™對所有皮膚類型都是安全的,並使用革命性的Nano Fractional Radio Frequency™(納米點陣射頻™)和Smart Scan™(智能掃描™)技術,通過選擇性真皮加熱,從而提供優異的治療效果。使用Nano Fractional RF™將能量透過表皮傳遞至真皮,從而產生熱量,並啟動膚膚的生理機制,重建膠原蛋白及刺激纖維母細胞,最終刺激導致組織重塑。功效:✔改善膚質✔肌膚緊緻✔減淡妊娠紋✔痤瘡及暗瘡疤痕✔減淡細紋及皺紋✔面部肌膚賦活再生 適合面部及頸部

  6. 全「身」趨勢!LSD真空無痛技術,無需使用冷凍啫喱,比傳統激光脫毛更安全,更舒適,更快捷。腿部背部永久脫毛,只需15分鐘!最快激光脫毛科技 配以22x35mm 及 9x9mm 治療機頭,比其他品牌之24mm為大,覆蓋肌膚範圍更廣。 因而更能縮短療程時間及次數。專為亞洲皮膚而設 因應不同膚色設定不同能量,無論膚色較深或較白均適用 最舒適及最有效的激光脫毛體驗 (與755nm及1064nm作比較) 設真空脫毛技術 LUMENIS LightSheer® Desire 激光脫毛儀備有真空脫毛技術,令激光能量更集中聚焦,達至更快及更有效之療程效果。

Comments are closed.